Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Explore Our Properties

Meet Nicole J. Youkstetter

Nicole J. Youkstetter McCall, ID Real Estate Agent Headshot

Nicole J. Youkstetter

Nicole is not just a REALTOR®; she’s your dedicated partner in the exciting journey of buying or selling your home. With a passion for real estate and a commitment to delivering outstanding service, Nicole has built a reputation for trustworthiness and results.

Nicole is inspired by a deep appreciation for the unique character and charm of homes dating all the way back to her childhood. Her parents owned rental properties and enlisted Nicole’s help on maintenance and remodeling projects at a young age. Her keen eye for detail, knowledge of the local market trends, and remodeling experience allow her to see the potential in every property, whether it’s a cozy starter home or a luxury estate.

Nicole is not only a skilled negotiator but also an excellent communicator. She takes the time to understand her clients’ unique needs and concerns, ensuring that every aspect of the real estate process is tailored to their needs. She brings decades of knowledge and experience to her work and makes sure her clients feel well-informed and comfortable every step of the way so they can make informed decisions and achieve their goals.

In addition to Nicole’s professional achievements, she prioritizes spending time with family and friends paddle boarding, snowboarding, boating, camping, and sleeping under the stars. Nicole and her husband live in McCall, where they raised three sons who come back to visit often. Nicole is deeply involved in the community where she volunteers her time and resources to support local causes like the Payette Lakes Progressive Club and the Little Ski Hill, among others. She believes giving back is an essential part of building strong, vibrant communities.

If you’re in the market to buy or sell a property, Nicole will go the extra mile to make your real estate experience as smooth and successful as possible. Reach out today!

Contact Details

Email address [email protected]
Primary phone (208) 315-5387
Address 102 N 3rd St Ste 200 McCall ID, 83638
License #AB35668

Testimonials

Nicole was the best. Very responsive and knowledgeable. She really helped us understand the local community and gave us very good advice. We would recommend her to our friends.
Nicole was the best. Very responsive and knowledgeable. She really helped us understand the local community and gave us very good advice. We would recommend her to our friends.
Pete H.
I have now bought one of Nicole’s listings, and she represented us for the purchase of a lot. She is a delight to work with, and I’ll never use anyone else!
I have now bought one of Nicole’s listings, and she represented us for the purchase of a lot. She is a delight to work with, and I’ll never use anyone else!
S. Nolan
Nicole was great to work with. She stayed with the plan even though it took two years to find the right home. When the purchasing process began, she kept me fully informed and provided assistance as needed right through closure. Nicole has continued to stay in touch, checking up, helping me with issues about being in a new community and environment.
Nicole was great to work with. She stayed with the plan even though it took two years to find the right home. When the purchasing process began, she kept me fully informed and provided assistance as needed right through closure. Nicole has continued to stay in touch, checking up, helping me with issues about being in a new community and environment.
Buyer
Thank you, Nicole. You went beyond our expectations when selling our home. I will highly recommend you to everyone I find looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you again!
Thank you, Nicole. You went beyond our expectations when selling our home. I will highly recommend you to everyone I find looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you again!
Bret R.
My husband and I took a leap of faith and moved our family to McCall about 2 months ago. I contacted Nicole immediately, as we wanted to get settled into a house quickly before the snow hit - she was always able to work with our hectic schedules when it came to showing us homes. After a couple of weeks, we found our forever home, made an offer, and Nicole made it happen! She was so great to work with, very knowledgeable about the community - we felt like we walked away with a great deal on a home and a friendship with Nicole. I highly recommend!
My husband and I took a leap of faith and moved our family to McCall about 2 months ago. I contacted Nicole immediately, as we wanted to get settled into a house quickly before the snow hit - she was always able to work with our hectic schedules when it came to showing us homes. After a couple of weeks, we found our forever home, made an offer, and Nicole made it happen! She was so great to work with, very knowledgeable about the community - we felt like we walked away with a great deal on a home and a friendship with Nicole. I highly recommend!
Whitney B.
Nicole is an excellent local realtor, and she really represented us and our interests well when we bought our home. She has good relationships with the other professionals in the industry, was able to make loads of recommendations for services and contractors, and has kept in touch to ensure we're melding into the community. Nicole Youkstetter is top-notch and has the knowledge, experience, and organization to be considered one of McCall's best realtors.
Nicole is an excellent local realtor, and she really represented us and our interests well when we bought our home. She has good relationships with the other professionals in the industry, was able to make loads of recommendations for services and contractors, and has kept in touch to ensure we're melding into the community. Nicole Youkstetter is top-notch and has the knowledge, experience, and organization to be considered one of McCall's best realtors.
Buyer
We listed with Nicole and had an offer within 2 weeks! Super easy to deal with and made it really convenient for us since we lived 3 hours away, and we closed in our own hometown.
We listed with Nicole and had an offer within 2 weeks! Super easy to deal with and made it really convenient for us since we lived 3 hours away, and we closed in our own hometown.
Seller
Nicole is a real professional. We listed our McCall lakeside property with her, and she had it sold within the time frame we were hoping for. She kept in constant communication with us through emails and phone calls and offered to assist us in property improvements and maintenance per buyer contingencies. We were very pleased with her services and those of AmeriTitle.
Nicole is a real professional. We listed our McCall lakeside property with her, and she had it sold within the time frame we were hoping for. She kept in constant communication with us through emails and phone calls and offered to assist us in property improvements and maintenance per buyer contingencies. We were very pleased with her services and those of AmeriTitle.
Seller
Was a pleasure working with Nicole. She took care of all of our questions and tried to meet our unique demands. We not only had a great real estate agent but also made a nice friend in the meantime.
Was a pleasure working with Nicole. She took care of all of our questions and tried to meet our unique demands. We not only had a great real estate agent but also made a nice friend in the meantime.
Buyer
Nicole has gone above and beyond what a normal realtor does. We told her our concerns, and she listened and guided us in the right direction. If anyone is thinking of buying property in the Ada, Cascade, McCall area, I would highly suggest using her. She will not steer you wrong, and will do everything she says she will do plus things you do not even think of. Best experience ever on buying property, and we have been purchasing property for 40 years.
Nicole has gone above and beyond what a normal realtor does. We told her our concerns, and she listened and guided us in the right direction. If anyone is thinking of buying property in the Ada, Cascade, McCall area, I would highly suggest using her. She will not steer you wrong, and will do everything she says she will do plus things you do not even think of. Best experience ever on buying property, and we have been purchasing property for 40 years.
Kenneth & Lorrena
In my 43 years, we have 6 properties, and we bought all of them without an agent. But with Nicole, she made us realize that in McCall, we needed a specialist. Nicole is very experienced with real estate law and knows what the market value is for a property, and what work it needs to come up to current standards. She is honest and has the greatest integrity I have known from an agent. She specializes in expensive properties and affordable properties. This makes her everyone's best agent. If you want to spend two hundred thousand or five hundred thousand, she knows her stuff. Thank you, Nicole.
In my 43 years, we have 6 properties, and we bought all of them without an agent. But with Nicole, she made us realize that in McCall, we needed a specialist. Nicole is very experienced with real estate law and knows what the market value is for a property, and what work it needs to come up to current standards. She is honest and has the greatest integrity I have known from an agent. She specializes in expensive properties and affordable properties. This makes her everyone's best agent. If you want to spend two hundred thousand or five hundred thousand, she knows her stuff. Thank you, Nicole.
The Mosh
Nicole was very pleasant to work with. She went out of her way to keep us informed as to what was going on with our listing. It took longer than we had hoped to make the sale, but bare, undeveloped property, way back in the hills, wasn't too much in demand at the time. Still, she hung in there, and things worked out well.
Nicole was very pleasant to work with. She went out of her way to keep us informed as to what was going on with our listing. It took longer than we had hoped to make the sale, but bare, undeveloped property, way back in the hills, wasn't too much in demand at the time. Still, she hung in there, and things worked out well.
Daniver
When you first meet Nicole, you know she is special and is willing to go the extra mile. With Nicole’s help, I found a property that I loved. I put in an offer, and the bank decided that it was now a short sale. The bank was slow to get things going; Nicole worked tirelessly with the bank, continually prodding them to get the sale done. It took six months for everything to be finalized, and Nicole’s dedication made it possible for me to get my little piece of heaven. In Nicole, I found an awesome Real Estate Agent and a wonderful friend. I highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking for their piece of heaven in the McCall area.
When you first meet Nicole, you know she is special and is willing to go the extra mile. With Nicole’s help, I found a property that I loved. I put in an offer, and the bank decided that it was now a short sale. The bank was slow to get things going; Nicole worked tirelessly with the bank, continually prodding them to get the sale done. It took six months for everything to be finalized, and Nicole’s dedication made it possible for me to get my little piece of heaven. In Nicole, I found an awesome Real Estate Agent and a wonderful friend. I highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking for their piece of heaven in the McCall area.
Buyer
Nicole has helped me purchase a couple of homes and sell them. She is unmatched in integrity and service. Nicole has always gone the extra mile on all my requests. Nicole fosters a positive interaction with other agents and professionals from Title Officers to Bank personnel. I highly recommend Nicole for all real estate needs. Her experience, knowledge, and enthusiasm are the best I have experienced in forty years of real estate investing.
Nicole has helped me purchase a couple of homes and sell them. She is unmatched in integrity and service. Nicole has always gone the extra mile on all my requests. Nicole fosters a positive interaction with other agents and professionals from Title Officers to Bank personnel. I highly recommend Nicole for all real estate needs. Her experience, knowledge, and enthusiasm are the best I have experienced in forty years of real estate investing.
Mike
Nicole salvaged a sale for us by negotiating a deal in which both agents, the buyer, and we as the sellers all gave a little bit to come to a workable price. It was very creative and moved us from a place where we assumed we were going to have to keep the house to a completed sale.
Nicole salvaged a sale for us by negotiating a deal in which both agents, the buyer, and we as the sellers all gave a little bit to come to a workable price. It was very creative and moved us from a place where we assumed we were going to have to keep the house to a completed sale.
Seller
Nicole was prompt, knowledgeable, and very professional in her dealings with us. We feel like we had the best agent possible in the McCall area for the sale of our home and purchase of a new one.
Nicole was prompt, knowledgeable, and very professional in her dealings with us. We feel like we had the best agent possible in the McCall area for the sale of our home and purchase of a new one.
Seller
We loved working with Nicole. She always gave us plenty of time while viewing and re-viewing properties. Each question and concern we had was met with a prompt response. She cared that we found just the right property for our family. We decided on a property that she had listed, and sometimes that can be uncomfortable in the negotiating process. We felt that she handled it in a very fair and professional way for both parties. We would certainly contact Nicole for any future real estate transactions, and we are looking forward to seeing her when we are in McCall. Thanks, Nicole - we love our new place!
We loved working with Nicole. She always gave us plenty of time while viewing and re-viewing properties. Each question and concern we had was met with a prompt response. She cared that we found just the right property for our family. We decided on a property that she had listed, and sometimes that can be uncomfortable in the negotiating process. We felt that she handled it in a very fair and professional way for both parties. We would certainly contact Nicole for any future real estate transactions, and we are looking forward to seeing her when we are in McCall. Thanks, Nicole - we love our new place!
Jason T.
Nicole was phenomenal in working with us on a short sale purchase that took over 6 months. She was patient, thorough, and went above and beyond to represent our interests in the negotiation and purchase. Especially since we were out-of-town buyers, she really made the extra effort to help us check on the property and arrange for local services in our absence. We are so grateful for her help and look forward to continuing our correspondence with her.
Nicole was phenomenal in working with us on a short sale purchase that took over 6 months. She was patient, thorough, and went above and beyond to represent our interests in the negotiation and purchase. Especially since we were out-of-town buyers, she really made the extra effort to help us check on the property and arrange for local services in our absence. We are so grateful for her help and look forward to continuing our correspondence with her.
Lawrence B.
Nicole represented our family in the sale of our lakeside condominium. It was complicated as several members of our extended family owned the unit. She was extremely patient and respectful of all the needs of all the owners. She maintained an exceptionally calm manner throughout all our negotiations and is a very charming and fun person to work with, making the selling process much less stressful. Her knowledge of Real Estate is extensive and would serve any future client well. We highly recommend Nicole.
Nicole represented our family in the sale of our lakeside condominium. It was complicated as several members of our extended family owned the unit. She was extremely patient and respectful of all the needs of all the owners. She maintained an exceptionally calm manner throughout all our negotiations and is a very charming and fun person to work with, making the selling process much less stressful. Her knowledge of Real Estate is extensive and would serve any future client well. We highly recommend Nicole.
Leather N.
Nicole is the best. She looked out for our needs and wants and was determined to help us find our home. She did this for over a year for us, never slowing down. Even after the house was ours, she continued to help us settle in the area. Not many real estate agents want anything to do with you after the checks are cashed. This is just what kind of person she is.
Nicole is the best. She looked out for our needs and wants and was determined to help us find our home. She did this for over a year for us, never slowing down. Even after the house was ours, she continued to help us settle in the area. Not many real estate agents want anything to do with you after the checks are cashed. This is just what kind of person she is.
Alexus N.

Find Your Dream Home

Home Search

Follow Us On Instagram